Q4 2026 Oil and Gas Carrier Update
Q4 2026 oil and gas carrier update for U.S. operators and contractors. Ratings, workers' comp market notes and renewal steps from Falcon West Energy.
Listen
The article on this page is the transcript.

Where carriers stand this quarter
This is Falcon West's Q4 2026 oil and gas carrier update. It covers who is writing workers' comp in the states where your crews work, what the ratings say, and what to bring to renewal.
Carrier ratings and stability
These market observations are based on policies we reviewed, not the full state market, and reflect carrier activity over the past year. Past placements do not guarantee current underwriting appetite.
AM Best Financial Strength Ratings (FSR) as published on AM Best or the carrier's own release, checked November 9, 2026.
Travelers: AM Best affirmed the A++ (Superior) rating of Travelers' main insurance companies, known as Travelers Group, with a stable outlook in August 2026. A++ is AM Best's highest rating. AM Best identifies Travelers as the second largest commercial lines writer in the country. Travelers reported a consolidated third-quarter combined ratio of 86.8% across all lines.
Berkley Oil & Gas (BOG): AM Best affirmed W. R. Berkley Insurance Group at A+ with a stable outlook in June 2026 and upgraded its issuer credit rating, citing the group's overall balance sheet strength. Berkley writes energy business through specialist units such as Berkley Oil & Gas. Berkley's third quarter consolidated combined ratio was 90.8%, not specific to oil and gas.
BITCO (Old Republic): AM Best affirmed Old Republic Insurance Companies at A+ with a stable outlook in April 2026. BITCO General Insurance Corporation and BITCO National Insurance Company are members of the group. Old Republic's Specialty Insurance segment reported a third-quarter combined ratio of 96.0%, up from 94.8% the previous year. This figure includes more than BITCO.
NAICO: AM Best affirmed National American Insurance Company at A with a stable outlook on October 1, 2026.
Texas Mutual: In the policies we reviewed, Texas Mutual leads oilfield workers' comp in Texas, especially in drilling and support services. AM Best rates it A+ with a stable outlook, affirmed in December 2025, and highlights its use of policyholder dividends for retention.
Contracts often require a minimum rating. Verify the rating of the specific underwriting company on your quote, not just the group. An A rating does not meet an A+ requirement. Ratings indicate financial strength, not claims service or coverage terms.
Travelers
Policy data shows Travelers is more active in California and Oklahoma oilfield accounts than in Texas, where Texas Mutual leads. Travelers also appears in extraction accounts in California and Pennsylvania. Where retention data is available, Travelers generally retained most oilfield accounts.
Carrier appetite varies by state and operation. Ask your Broker to confirm interest for your specific work.
Berkley Oil & Gas (BOG)
Policy data shows Berkley maintains a consistent presence in support services accounts across Texas, Oklahoma, New Mexico, and California, though it is not a market leader.
At renewal, consider Berkley as a specialist option alongside the state fund or mutual. If a customer contract calls for A+, confirm that the Berkley company on your quote meets an A+ requirement.
BITCO (Old Republic)
Policy data shows the Old Republic group in support services accounts in every featured state (Texas, Oklahoma, New Mexico, California, and Pennsylvania), with a notable position in Texas extraction, where it held most of the accounts it wrote. These results reflect the entire Old Republic group, not just BITCO.
At renewal, BITCO (Old Republic) is a known energy market. BITCO focuses on onshore oil and gas operators, drillers, and contractors.
NAICO
Policy data shows NAICO has a much larger presence in Oklahoma, its home state, than in Texas, for both extraction and support services. NAICO also appears in Pennsylvania extraction accounts. In Oklahoma, it retained most accounts it wrote.
At renewal, NAICO is a key market in Oklahoma. Some customers require A+ or higher, and NAICO is rated A.
The state funds and mutuals
In Oklahoma, New Mexico, and California, the state fund or state mutual led the support services accounts we reviewed, though with less concentration than Texas Mutual holds in Texas. CompSource Mutual is rated A. New Mexico Mutual reports an AM Best rating of A- (Excellent). California's State Fund does not carry an AM Best rating and instead publishes its capital and surplus measures.
Among support services accounts, carrier switching was more frequent in Oklahoma and New Mexico than in Texas.
State fund states
North Dakota, Wyoming, Ohio, and Washington are monopolistic states. Employers must buy workers' comp from the state fund. Ohio and Washington also allow qualified employers to self insure. These state fund policies do not provide employers' liability, so stop gap employers' liability is usually added by endorsement to the workers' comp policy covering your other states, or to the general liability policy. Monopolistic states cannot be listed under Part Three Other States Insurance, so crews working there need a state fund account before work starts. Confirm with your Broker how coverage applies in every state where employees work or may be assigned.
Why the basin changes your insurance
Your basin is more than a location on your application; it directly affects your insurance program.
State law often follows the well site. Anti-indemnity statutes vary across Texas, Louisiana, New Mexico, Wyoming, and other producing states. The same indemnity clause in your MSA may be enforceable in one state but not another. If you operate across state lines, your contracts and insurance should be reviewed for each state where you work. See When the MSA Doesn't Save You and Hammer Clauses and Knock-for-Knock for more information.
Workers' comp requirements vary by state. Rates, credits, and rules change at state lines, which is important when crews move between locations. See Workers' Comp Premium Credits by State.
The relevant regulator determines bonding requirements. Each state's oil and gas regulator, as well as the BLM for federal land, sets plugging and reclamation bonds. Entering a new basin may require a new bond. Refer to our Oil and Gas Well Bonding Guide.
Getting ready for renewal
A loss cost multiplier is a pricing factor in workers' comp, not the final rate. Ask your Broker to review the experience rating worksheets for your operations and explain how they affect each quote.
Review insurance policy red flags with your contracts. Match each contract's rating requirement to the underwriting company on the quote, not the group.
Begin workers' comp audit preparation early by gathering current operations details, payroll estimates by state, loss runs, and contracts.
FAQ
Does a group rating satisfy my contract's insurance requirement?
Verify the rating of the specific underwriting company listed on your quote, not just the group. An A rating does not satisfy an A+ requirement. Ratings reflect financial strength, not claims service or coverage terms.
Does past policy data show where a carrier will quote today?
No. Market observations reflect only the policies reviewed, not the entire state market. Past placements do not indicate current underwriting appetite. Ask your Broker to confirm carrier interest for your specific work and states.
What if our crews work in a monopolistic workers' comp state?
North Dakota, Wyoming, Ohio, and Washington cannot be listed under Part Three Other States Insurance, so crews working there need a state fund account before work starts. Ask your Broker to confirm state fund requirements and stop gap employers' liability coverage.
Methodology and sources
Market observations are based on Insurance Xdate workers' compensation policy data accessed in November 2026, covering policies expiring in the previous 12 months for oil and gas extraction, drilling, support services, and pipeline NAICS codes in Texas, Oklahoma, New Mexico, California, Pennsylvania, and Alaska. Monopolistic state fund data did not identify carriers and was not used. Positions are measured by account at the carrier group level, not by premium. Alaska and several drilling and pipeline samples were too small to support conclusions. Ratings are from AM Best and carrier releases linked above, checked November 9, 2026. Quarterly results reflect company wide or segment performance, not specifically oil and gas results.
Carrier ratings and quarterly results: AM Best, carrier announcements and financial releases linked in the carrier sections above.


